By Mike Romero
With discussions surrounding school closures, boundary changes, and the potential formation of new school districts in Orem, the Orem City Council took action on Tuesday by implementing changes to various zones, consolidating them into a single Public Facilities Zone.
The vote in favor of the zone change was 6-1, with Council member Tom Macdonald casting the lone dissenting vote. Macdonald expressed concerns about the lack of communication and collaboration with the school district prior to issuing public notices about the proposed changes.
The purpose of the new zone is to safeguard public land for future educational institutions and parks. It also serves as a preemptive measure to prevent the Alpine School District from selling its land without obtaining approval from the Orem Planning Commission and City Council. Approximately 90% of Orem’s land is already developed.
Council members emphasized their apprehension regarding future growth and land requirements, especially considering the possibility of private and charter schools being established in the city. This concern was heightened after the legislature approved $8,000 in funding for each student, regardless of the type of school they attend. This includes public, private, charter, or homeschooling—according to Ryan Clark, assistant city manager.
During the public hearing, questions were raised regarding whether the rezoning was intended to facilitate the sale of Alpine School District (ASD) properties at a lower price. However, it was clarified that the city had paid the appraised value for Hillcrest Elementary when it closed, and the same principle would apply to other schools. The city holds the first right to purchase any school property according to state law.
Council member Terry Peterson argued that ASD had closed Hillcrest Elementary, Geneva Elementary, and Polaris High School without any financial compensation being returned to Orem schools. Tensions between Orem city government and Alpine School District have run high in recent years.
“I think we can do more by working together,” Council member Jeff Lambson stated.
City attorney Stephen Earl recommended preserving the property, citing concerns about the irreversible loss of land if ASD were to sell it to developers. He questioned where schools would be built in the future if the need arose.
“As far as I’m concerned, regardless of ASD’s involvement, this is simply a matter of common sense,” Mayor Dave Young asserted. “We never anticipated school closures. Amidst all this uncertainty, we must preserve our lands.”
